Unacceptable Attacks on Workers'
Rights
Alberta Government Passes Bill 1, the Critical Infrastructure Defence Act
- Peggy Morton -
The first order of business for the Kenney
government when the Alberta legislation resumed
on May 27 was Bill 1, the Critical
Infrastructure Defence Act. The
legislation was passed the following day.
The Act gives the government and police
arbitrary powers to attack workers, women,
youth, seniors, Indigenous peoples and everyone
who is affirming their rights and the laying
their claims. Bill 1 makes it an offence to
"without lawful right, justification or excuse,
wilfully obstruct, interrupt or interfere with
the construction, maintenance, use or operation
of any essential infrastructure in a manner that
renders the essential infrastructure dangerous,
useless, inoperative or ineffective."
It also creates an offence to aid, counsel, or
direct another person to commit an offence under
the Act, irrespective of whether the other
person actually commits the offence. It is also
an offence to enter essential infrastructure
having obtained permission by false pretenses.
All of this creates an offence so broad that it
could mean almost anything, which is clearly the
intention.
In addition to a
long list of "essential infrastructure" which
includes pipelines, oil and gas production and
refinery sites, mines, utilities, highways,
railways, telecommunications, agricultural
sites, and the land on which infrastructure is
located, the Bill also defines "essential
infrastructure" as "a building, structure,
device or other thing prescribed by the
regulations." Regulations are enacted under the
prerogative or police powers of the executive
and can be changed at any time by executive
decision. In short -- "essential infrastructure"
is anything the government declares it to be,
including public space. Under this law police
can make arrests without obtaining a warrant or
injunction.
Bill 1 provides penalties of up to $10,000 for
a first offence, up to $25,000 for subsequent
offences, plus possible prison time of up to six
months, and up to $200,000 for "corporations
that help or direct trespassers." Each day that
a "contravention" exists constitutes a new
offence.
The bill has evoked a storm of criticism from
the Indigenous peoples, workers and their
organizations, human rights organizations, legal
experts and many others, and the government's
claim that it is "upholding law and order" has
been met with the contempt it deserves.
Bill 1 was first introduced on February 25
immediately following the Speech from the
Throne, with the government attacking all those
standing with the Wet'suwet'en people, and
blaming them for all the problems facing the
economy in Alberta. Premier Jason Kenney and
others referred to the land defenders as "thugs"
and "ecoterrorists" at one time and "spoiled
kids" and "professional protesters" at another.
Introducing the bill in February, Alberta
Minister of Justice Doug Schweitzer said, "Over
the last number of weeks, we've seen growing
lawlessness across the country, pushing our
railway lines to grind to a halt," This is
simply unacceptable. This is a mockery of our
democratically founded country. So we're now
taking decisive action to respond to this."
No such declarations have been made about the
negligence of CN and CP and the growing number
of rail accidents in Canada, with 1,170 rail
accidents in 2018 alone, leading not just to
temporary disruption of the rail system but to
the deaths of railway workers. Law and order
does not apply to the energy oligarchs when it
comes to mitigating the damage they cause to the
environment. The pandemic even became a pretext
to suspend the entire regulatory system
governing the operation of oil and gas
companies. There is no rule of law when
governments act as though Indigenous law has
been extinguished, violate treaties in which
Indigenous peoples agreed to share the land on a
nation-to-nation basis, and refuse to uphold
Canada's obligations under international law.
Alberta public sector workers rally, November
20, 2019, against government's neo-liberal
wrecking of public services.
Bill 1 is also directed against workers who
defend their rights through strike action, and
against the resistance to the anti-social
offensive and the united stand and No! of the
public sector workers who the government calls
heroes today and plans to throw out onto the
street later. It is intended to target workers
defending their picket lines, which are already
confined by injunctions and other means intended
to make them ineffective. Bill 1 adds to the
arsenal used to impose huge fines on unions
which uphold the right of workers to decide the
wages and working conditions acceptable to them.
Resources at the
disposal of the state come from the wealth
created by the working people. But instead of
being used to benefit the people, they are used
to impose the rule of the rich. The Beaver Lake
Cree Nation (BLCN) are in court once again, as
the federal and Alberta governments appeal the
lower court decision to award advance costs to
the BLCN to advance their legal case that
regulatory bodies must consider cumulative
effects of development on their traditional
territories. For 12 years, since the BLCN
launched the legal challenge, governments have
tried to block them and drain their financial
resources every step of the way. Fines of
hundreds of thousands of dollars are levied
against unions who defend the right of their
members to decide what wages and working
conditions are acceptable to them using unjust
laws which criminalize their collective actions.
Bill 1 shows just what Kenney means when he says
he will do "whatever is necessary" to defend the
interests of the energy oligarchs, and that the
government has lost all claims to legitimacy.
What remains of the public authority is the use
of police powers to enforce the rule of the
rich, no matter what.
This may be called "rule of law" but it does
not make it so. There is already a line-up to
challenge Bill 1 as illegal and a violation of
the Charter
or civil right to freedom of expression and
freedom of assembly. It will also certainly be
challenged by the people in action to defend
their human rights as well as their civil
rights. When laws do not recognize the rights
which belong to people by virtue of their being,
including the sovereign rights of Indigenous
peoples and the rights of workers as the
producers of all social value, a serious problem
arises. This refusal creates a conflict between
the authority and the modern conditions. That is
a big problem facing the people and society,
which needs to be addressed and resolved. It is
not a problem which can be sorted out by using
force and violence in the name of "law and
order."
Whether or not Bill 1 is found to be
unconstitutional, which is quite possible, it is
certainly in contempt of a modern understanding
of the purpose of law to serve the cause of
justice. When the law is not seen to be just,
and when it is imposed through arbitrary powers
in an attempt to threaten, intimidate, bully,
and criminalize those who are defending their
rights and the rights of all, it cannot be
called rule of law.
The need for democratic renewal to provide the
working people with a say in governance and for
nation-to-nation relations between Canada and
the Indigenous peoples has never been more
urgent. Bill 1 must be repealed!
Our Security Lies in the Fight
for the Rights of All!
This article was published in
Number 39 - June 9, 2020
Article Link:
Unacceptable Attacks on Workers'
Rights: Alberta Government Passes Bill 1, the Critical Infrastructure Defence Act - Peggy Morton
Website: www.cpcml.ca
Email: editor@cpcml.ca
|